Skip to main content
Articles

Who has the right to the forest? Multispecies political ecology and the contestation of legitimacies in the Bukit Tigapuluh Forest Landscape, Tebo, Indonesia

Authors

Abstract

The Bukit Tigapuluh forest landscape in Tebo, Indonesia, has become an arena of contestation involving indigenous peoples, migrant communities, corporations, NGOs, the state, and non-human species. This study examines how competing claims over forests are legitimized through historical, legal, economic, and ecological narratives using a multispecies political ecology approach. The research focuses on interactions among Talang Mamak, Orang Rimba, migrant farmers, industrial plantation companies, ecosystem restoration actors, and conservation organizations operating around the Bukit Tigapuluh National Park landscape. This research employed an ethnographic approach conducted in Dusun Simarantihan, Desa Suo-Suo, Desa Muaro Sekalo, and Desa Pemayungan in Sumay District, Tebo Regency, Jambi Province. Data were collected through participant observation, in-depth interviews and field immersion involving indigenous communities, local migrants, company representatives, NGOs, and government actors. The analysis combined political ecology and multispecies ethnography to understand contested forest governance. The findings show that overlapping forms of legitimacy shape forest governance in Bukit Tigapuluh. Talang Mamak and Orang Rimba communities claim forests through historical occupation, swidden cultivation, mobility, and customary relations with rivers and forests. Meanwhile, the state and corporations legitimize forest control through changing legal regimes, including logging concessions (HPH), industrial plantation forests (HTI), ecosystem restoration concessions, and sustainable rubber plantation schemes. NGOs and corporate conservation programs further construct ecological legitimacy by positioning elephants and orangutans as endangered species requiring habitat protection, wildlife corridors, and ecosystem restoration. However, these conservation initiatives also generate new territorial restrictions and conflicts over land access and livelihoods among indigenous and local communities. The Bukit Tigapuluh landscape reflects a multispecies political ecology in which struggles over forests are not merely disputes over land and resources, but also contests over whose histories, livelihoods, ecological knowledge, and non-human relations are recognized as legitimate in shaping forest futures.

Keywords: multispecies political ecology, forest lagitimacy, conservation conflict, Bukit Tigapuluh

How to Cite:

Tresno, , Cahyadi, V., Maxey, W., Rahmilija, F., Oktanedi, A. & , D., (2026) “Who has the right to the forest? Multispecies political ecology and the contestation of legitimacies in the Bukit Tigapuluh Forest Landscape, Tebo, Indonesia”, Journal of Political Ecology 33(1): 10855. doi: https://doi.org/10.2458/jpe.10855

Downloads:
Download PDF
View PDF

Funding

Name
Indonesian Conservation Community (KKI-Warsi)

351 Views

92 Downloads

Published on
2026-10-04

Peer Reviewed