Abstract
In 1969, half of all students walked or biked to school. By 2023, only one in ten students did so. Instead, the majority of children today get to school in a car driven by a parent. Although multiple forces drive this trend away from walking, school transportation policies play an outsized role in determining children’s mobility options. Across the United States, school districts are quietly adopting policies that prohibit or restrict children from walking to school. These policies are typically justified in the name of safety and administrative convenience, but they operate as significant restraints on parental rights and children’s everyday movement.
This Article examines whether public school students have a right to walk to school. In doing so, this Article focuses on the intersection of parental authority, children’s individual liberties, and the state’s responsibility for child welfare and safe streets. First, this Article explores the right to walk to school from the state’s perspective. This side of the conflict has two components: the state’s powers to design unsafe streets and the state’s interest in student safety in light of those safety concerns. School districts often defend walking restrictions by framing them as measures to prevent traffic accidents. Yet this Article questions whether broad prohibitions are narrowly tailored to serve that interest and whether alternatives (such as improved pedestrian infrastructure or more tailored walk-to-school policies) could achieve safety goals while preserving parental and student rights.
Second, this Article considers the extent to which parental rights insulate decisions about school transportation from excessive state interference. Building on the Supreme Court’s parental rights jurisprudence, which affirms the fundamental right of parents to direct the care, custody, and control of their children, this Article argues that restrictions on walking may impermissibly intrude on parental autonomy absent a compelling safety risk.
Finally, this Article explores whether children themselves possess a constitutionally protected right to walk to school. Although the Constitution does not expressly provide such a right, some courts have recognized certain free-movement rights (such as the right to intrastate travel or the right to locomotion) in other contexts. This Article analyzes whether prohibitions on walking impose undue burdens on children’s freedom of movement, comparing them to curfew laws that have been invalidated for restricting individuals’ mobility without sufficient justification.
Taken together, these analyses provide a framework for evaluating the constitutionality of school transportation policies. This Article concludes that restrictions on walking implicate foundational questions about parental authority, children’s liberties, and the scope of state power. Courts, school districts, and urban planners should therefore adopt approaches that balance child safety with respect for family autonomy and student freedom of movement.
How to Cite
68 Ariz. L. Rev. 685 (2026).
56
Views
17
Downloads